Comic of the Day 25/4: "Action Comics" #51

There's not much going on in Action Comics #51. It's still enjoyable, but as a part of the larger "The Search for Supergirl" story arc, it falls into the old trap of not sufficiently existing in its own right. While it starts out with a spectacularly paced action scene that sees Superman take his daughter away from the D.E.O., the comic doesn't have much too offer afterwards, with an apparent lack of pace or tension.

Peter J. Tomasi's dialogue between Supergirl and her father is stale and clichéd, while Paul Pelletier's pencils and Tomeu Morey's colours are often too playful to add a real dramatic tone to the story. Taking some risks would have benefited Action Comics #51, as its safe approach does not allow for too much creativity or fun.